Mice Keep Coming Back After the Exterminator? Here's Why
Straight answers from Silver Bullet Pest Control, a licensed exterminator based in Garfield, NJ, serving Bergen, Passaic, Essex and Hudson counties. Call or text 973-510-2585. Hablamos espaΓ±ol.
Featured on Telemundo 47 β’ EPA Pesticide Safety Certified β’ 4.9 Stars on Google β’ NJ License 90568B
Text a photo of what you're seeing and we'll tell you what it is and what to do.
- β Same-day appointments often available
- β Licensed & insured in NJ
- β Homes & businesses
- β English & EspaΓ±ol
Quick answer: the holes were never sealed
Why do mice keep coming back after an exterminator? Almost always because the holes they use to get in were never sealed. Traps and bait only remove the mice already inside; new ones keep walking in through gaps at pipes, the foundation, garage doors and the roofline. Silver Bullet Pest Control finds and seals those entry points (exclusion), then traps what's left. The inspection is free. Rodent service comes with 90 days of coverage and unlimited free service calls during that time. Call or text 973-510-2585. NJ License 90568B.
The three reasons mice come back
| Reason | What it looks like | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Entry points never sealed | New droppings weeks after the last mouse was caught | Seal gaps with steel mesh, metal and sealant, not foam alone |
| Bait only, no follow-up | Quiet for a while, then noises again | Check and reset traps and stations until activity stops |
| Food and nesting spots left open | Activity near pantry, stove, boiler or clutter | Sealed containers, clear storage areas, fix leaks |
Where mice get into North Jersey homes
- Where gas, water and AC lines go through the wall
- Gaps under garage and basement doors
- Cracks along the foundation and sill plate
- Dryer vents and crawl space vents
- Rooflines, soffits and where a porch or addition meets the house
Older two-family homes and attached houses are common in our area and often have many small gaps. A mouse can fit through a hole about the size of a dime.
What we see on these jobs
The three situations behind most of these calls in North Jersey:

Mouse Treatment Inside the Home
- Small droppings in drawers and cabinets
- Chewed food packaging
- Scratching in walls at night
Our One-Time Mouse Service is 100% guaranteed, and mice and rodent service includes 90 days of coverage with unlimited free service calls in that time.

Rats Around the House
- Bigger, capsule-shaped droppings
- Burrows along the foundation
- Gnawing on wood, plastic or wires
Rats are wary and harder to trap than mice. The lasting fix is finding the burrows and gaps they use and closing them.

Sealing the Way In
- Gaps around pipes and gas lines
- Garage door seals
- Foundation cracks and vents
Trapping handles the rodents inside. Sealing the gaps with steel and the right materials is what stops the next ones.
What we do differently
Free inspection, inside and out
We find every entry point and where they're nesting.
Seal the entry points
Exclusion with materials mice can't chew through. See stainless steel mesh exclusion.
Trap what's inside
Traps and tamper-resistant stations placed where the activity is.
Come back until it stops
Rodent service comes with 90 days of coverage and unlimited free service calls during that time.
When to call
If you've already paid for treatment and still hear scratching or find droppings, call or text 973-510-2585. Same-day service is available. Calls are answered 24/7 and a technician can come at any hour; arrival time depends on your location. See also rodent control and exclusion.
Simple ways to prevent it
Seal small gaps
Close gaps around pipes, cables and vents with steel wool plus sealant or metal mesh. Foam alone gets chewed through.
Fix door sweeps
Garage and basement doors need tight bottom seals. A gap you can slide a pencil under lets mice in.
Store food sealed
Keep cereal, rice, pet food and birdseed in glass, metal or hard plastic.
Clear the perimeter
Keep firewood, leaf piles and dense shrubs away from the foundation.
How Silver Bullet handles it
Call or text a photo
Tell us what you're seeing and where. A photo often lets us identify the pest right away. We answer 24/7 for emergencies.
Inspection
A licensed tech finds the source: where the pest lives, how it gets in and what draws it.
Treatment or removal
We use the right method for the pest, placed where it works and kept away from kids and pets.
Seal and prevent
We close entry points and tell you what to change so the problem doesn't come back.
Related services
Get Help From a Licensed Exterminator
Call or text 973-510-2585 for the fastest answer, or tell us what's going on and we'll get back to you quickly.
Calls we get every week
- Mice in the kitchen or pantry
- Scratching in the walls or ceiling at night
- Rats burrowing in the yard or under a deck
- Droppings in the garage or basement
- Rodents in an apartment building or restaurant
Request Service
π Your info stays private Β· Hablamos espaΓ±ol.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do I still have mice after the exterminator came?
Usually the entry points weren't sealed, so new mice keep coming in. Trapping alone doesn't stop that.
How long does it take to get rid of mice?
It depends on how many entry points there are and how many mice are inside. Once entry points are sealed, activity usually drops off as the remaining mice are trapped.
Do you seal the holes?
Yes. Finding and sealing entry points (exclusion) is part of how we handle mice.
Is there a warranty?
Rodent service comes with 90 days of coverage and unlimited free service calls during that time.
Is the inspection free?
Yes. The inspection is free.
What if I keep seeing mice after treatment?
Mice and rodent service includes 90 days of coverage with unlimited free service calls, so we come back.
Do you treat apartment buildings and restaurants?
Yes. We handle rodents in multi-family buildings and food businesses and can set up ongoing service.
How do I clean up droppings safely?
Air out the room, wear gloves, spray with disinfectant, wait five minutes, wipe with paper towels and bag them. Never sweep or vacuum dry droppings.
Do mice come back every fall?
Often, yes. As it gets cold, mice look for warm shelter, so fall is the busiest time. Sealing gaps before then helps a lot.
Can mice chew through walls?
They can chew through drywall, wood, plastic and foam. Steel, metal mesh and concrete stop them.
How much does mouse control cost?
It depends on the size of the home and how many entry points need sealing. Call or text 973-510-2585 for a quote.
ΒΏHablan espaΓ±ol?
SΓ. Hablamos espaΓ±ol. Llame o envΓe un texto al 973-510-2585.
Serving North Jersey
Based in Garfield, we serve these towns and the rest of Bergen, Passaic, Essex and Hudson counties.
Our service area
Bergen County
973-510-2585- Allendale
- Bergenfield
- Bogota
- Carlstadt
- Cliffside Park
- Closter
- Cresskill
- Demarest
- Dumont
- East Rutherford
- Edgewater
- Elmwood Park
- Emerson
- Englewood
- Englewood Cliffs
- Fair Lawn
- Fairview
- Fort Lee
- Franklin Lakes
- Garfield
- Glen Rock
- Hackensack
- Harrington Park
- Hasbrouck Heights
- Haworth
- Hillsdale
- Ho-Ho-Kus
- Leonia
- Little Ferry
- Lodi
- Lyndhurst
- Mahwah
- Maywood
- Midland Park
- Montvale
- Moonachie
- New Milford
- North Arlington
- Northvale
- Norwood
- Oakland
- Old Tappan
- Oradell
- Palisades Park
- Paramus
- Park Ridge
- Ramsey
- Ridgefield
- Ridgefield Park
- Ridgewood
- River Edge
- River Vale
- Rochelle Park
- Rutherford
- Saddle Brook
- Saddle River
- South Hackensack
- Teaneck
- Tenafly
- Teterboro
- Upper Saddle River
- Waldwick
- Wallington
- Washington Township
- Westwood
- Woodcliff Lake
- Wood-Ridge
- Wyckoff
Passaic County
973-510-2585- Bloomingdale
- Clifton
- Haledon
- Hawthorne
- Little Falls
- North Haledon
- Passaic
- Paterson
- Pompton Lakes
- Prospect Park
- Ringwood
- Totowa
- Wanaque
- Wayne
- West Milford
- Woodland Park
Essex County
973-510-2585- Belleville
- Bloomfield
- Caldwell
- Cedar Grove
- East Orange
- Essex Fells
- Fairfield
- Glen Ridge
- Irvington
- Livingston
- Maplewood
- Millburn
- Montclair
- Newark
- North Caldwell
- Nutley
- Orange
- Roseland
- Short Hills
- South Orange
- Verona
- West Caldwell
- West Orange
Hudson County
973-510-2585Union County
973-510-2585- Berkeley Heights
- Clark
- Cranford
- Elizabeth
- Fanwood
- Garwood
- Hillside
- Kenilworth
- Linden
- Mountainside
- New Providence
- Plainfield
- Rahway
- Roselle
- Roselle Park
- Scotch Plains
- Springfield
- Summit
- Union
- Westfield
Morris County
973-510-2585- Boonton
- Butler
- Cedar Knolls
- Chatham
- Denville
- Dover
- East Hanover
- Florham Park
- Hanover
- Kinnelon
- Lincoln Park
- Madison
- Mendham
- Montville
- Morris Plains
- Morristown
- Mountain Lakes
- Parsippany
- Pequannock
- Randolph
- Riverdale
- Rockaway
- Roxbury
- Whippany
Updated November 2026 by the Silver Bullet Pest Control team, Garfield, NJ β’ NJ License 90568B
